Technocratic law inflicts symbolic violence on human subjects by imposing upon them a reductionist vision of their existence, limited to the aspect of homo oeconomicus passivus. At the same time, this symbolic violence serves to achieve the main technocratic goal of the depoliticisation of decision-making. Law is perceived through the optic of instrumental rationality, while juridification has nothing to do with justice,but merely serves to insulate technocratic decision-making from the political sphere. This paper enquires whether, in the process of its judicial interpretation, the humanizationof technocratic law can lead to its repoliticisation. On the basis of case studiesof three well-known judgments of the European Court of Justice (Leitner, Omegaand Aziz), the article makes the assertion that indeed, humanization can be instrumentalto repoliticisation. However, by referring to the judgment in Alemo-Herron, the author draws the final conclusion that politicisation is only the first step, and a further one is to ask specifically about the subject of interests protected by the law.
May 20, 2020
Jan 8, 2018
|Symbolic violence in technocratic lawand attempts at its overcoming : politicisation through humanization?||May 20, 2020|
Paśko, Marta Jedlecka, Wioletta Red. Helios, Joanna Red. Kwieciński, Adam Red. Chmielnicki, Paweł Rec.
Bobin, Ewa Chmielnicki, Paweł Rec. Jedlecka, Wioletta Red. Helios, Joanna Red. Kwieciński, Adam Red.
Czuchryta, Joanna Matyszewska, Katarzyna Kostecka-Jurczyk, Daria. Red. Jakubowski, Sebastian. Red.
Bator, Andrzej Kaczmarek, Przemysław Bator, Andrzej Red. Kaczmarek, Przemysław. Red.
Zajadło, Jerzy Bator, Andrzej Red. Kaczmarek, Przemysław. Red.
Zirk-Sadowski, Marek (1952- ) Bator, Andrzej Red. Kaczmarek, Przemysław. Red.
Dobosz, Damian Kostecka-Jurczyk, Daria. Red. Jakubowski, Sebastian. Red.
Kimla, Piotr Maciejewski, Marek. Red. Scheffler, Tomasz. Red. Antonów, Radosław. Red.